Koach founder Dennis Boekhout on two reports from coaches, a team with two liberos and a team with three middles, and what came out of them: roles per match, a fill-in as libero, and a libero who, since version 3.1, waits one rally.
The automatic libero swap in Koach was built for the usual case: one libero coming in at the back for two middles. That’s how plenty of teams play. But a team is allowed to register two liberos, and there are lots of teams with three players who play in the middle. That’s exactly where the automation hit its limits.
Dennis Boekhout talks about two reports from coaches, what changed in the app afterwards, and why since version 3.1 the libero sometimes waits a rally before he comes in.
“At the end of September a coach with two liberos reported that after a swap his second libero rotated along into the front row and didn’t come off again. A few days later a coach with three middles got in touch: he’d turned the automation off and after that couldn’t get his libero off the court.
“Two different problems, but the same cause. In the app’s head there was one libero and two middles. Anything that didn’t fit that fell through the cracks.”
“The match started with the first libero, and that went fine. But the app only knew about one. When the coach swapped the second one in, the app saw a regular player in that spot. So he just rotated along to the front, and that’s where he stayed.
“Worse still: a bit later the app put the first libero back in, because as far as the app was concerned he was off the court. Then you’ve got two liberos on court and a middle has vanished. I fixed that the same day.”
“That the libero is now whoever is on court as the libero. Not that one name filled in for the team. If you swap your second libero in, he takes over the role, with everything that comes with it: staying in the back row, not serving, coming off when his middle rotates to the front.
“And a swap between the two liberos doesn’t count towards your substitutions, because under the rules it isn’t a substitution. During the set you tap your libero and pick the other one. That list also shows who he’s on court for.”
“With the automation off, the coach had to swap the libero himself, and it went wrong when putting the player back. The player the libero was in for counted as ‘on court’ for the app, so he couldn’t come in twice. Because of that he wasn’t anywhere in the substitution list. The app did warn that the libero was in the front row, but there was no button with it.
“A warning with no way out is the worst thing an app can do. Now there’s a button next to the warning, with the name of the player who has to go back on. And if you tap the libero, that player is there too, with a button to put him back on court.”
“Because the position in a player’s profile doesn’t tell you what he’s playing today. For example: your third middle is playing opposite this week, or your second libero plays as a court player because someone’s ill. In October, emails from clubs asked for a way to choose that per match. That’s now in Prepare match and in the set break: ‘Roles in this match’ and ‘Roles in set’ with the number of the set.
“Under the middles you tick who the libero comes in for at the back. Under the liberos you can assign two at most, and if you untick one, that libero just plays as a court player. The positions in the player profiles stay as they are. It’s a choice for this match, not for the season.”
“Since the end of October, yes. A guest player, someone who comes over from another team to fill in, can be setter, middle or libero in the roles. He has no position in your team, so the role only applies to that match. The automatic libero swap knows him too, and that stays the case if you let someone else keep score.
“Youth teams and recreational teams often have someone filling in. Your libero is ill, someone from another team takes his place, and then you don’t want the app treating him like a court player who rotates to the front.”
“That came from the coach with three middles again. The rules say there has to be a completed rally between two libero replacements. With three middles it can happen that one middle rotates to the front while another one arrives in the back row at the same time. The app then let the libero switch in one move: off for one, on for the other.
“Now he waits. The third middle plays that one rally himself, and after that the libero comes in for him automatically. That also applies when someone else is keeping score. Update the app through the App Store or Google Play and you’ve got it.”
“For one rally there’s a middle in the back row where you’d expect the libero. That’s not a bug in the app, that’s the rule. If you don’t know that, it might give you a bit of a fright, and that’s why I’d rather explain it here than have someone find out in the gym.
“There’s one more consequence. If the automation is on and you take the libero off by hand, he just comes back after the next rally. If you really want to keep him off the court for a while, you turn ‘Libero auto swap’ off.”
“It doesn’t decide who your middles are. You tick that yourself, and the app tells you if there aren’t two, because usually there are two. It doesn’t pick a second libero on its own either: you can assign a player who has libero as his second position, but he never becomes libero automatically.
“And more than two liberos isn’t possible, because it isn’t allowed either. Beyond that, I don’t want a coach to have to think about it during a set. Everything I build into it is there so your libero is where he belongs, without you having to tap.”
Tick your middles and liberos when you prepare the match, and Koach keeps the libero in the back row where he belongs all match long. Free to try, with your own team.
Try Koach free