Holding the evaluation talk with a player

The evaluation talk is the most important fifteen minutes between coach and player — and the most frequently improvised. Come with data and a structure, and a box-ticking exercise becomes a conversation players remember for years.

Reading time: 6 min

The preparation: open the player page

Everything you need is on one screen: the personal goal and its progress, the season statistics, the form, the attendance and your notes from the entire season. Pick three things from it in advance: one piece of proof of growth, one pattern to discuss, one question you genuinely do not know the answer to. A fifteen-minute conversation needs no more preparation than that — and no less.

The player page in the Koach app with goal, statistics and attendance as the basis for the conversation — The player page is your case file: goal, numbers, form and notes on one screen.

The structure: first them, then the data, then together

Open with their view (3 min): "how do you look back on your season?" — and then really listen. Their self-image determines how every number lands later.
Lay the data next to it (5 min): show the player page, literally. Start with what matches their story, then name one difference ("you feel it was a bad season; your numbers say: best blocking year so far").
Look ahead together (5 min): what will the goal be for the coming period, and what do they need from you to get there? Almost no coach asks that last question — and it yields the most.

The pitfalls

The monologue: if you talk more than half the time, it was an assessment, not a conversation.
The number dump: three data points, chosen by you. The player can scroll for themselves afterwards.
The comparison: "Sven does that better" poisons everything. Compare the player only with themselves — that is what the data was built for.
The surprise effect: nothing in this conversation should be new. A coach who gave small doses of feedback all season evaluates; a coach who stayed silent ambushes.

Plan two talks per season, not one. One talk in May is a retrospective without consequences. A mid-season talk during the winter break makes course corrections possible — and takes the tension out of the end-of-season talk.

Frequently asked questions

How long should an evaluation talk take?

Fifteen to twenty minutes is enough with good preparation. Longer rarely makes it better — the quality is in the three points you chose and the question of what the player needs from you.

Should I also hold talks with bench players and youth players?

Especially with them: the starter gets feedback all season long, the bench player often only silence. The same goes for youth in a shorter format — ten minutes, one compliment with proof, one growth point.

What if the player fundamentally disagrees with my view?

Then the talk has succeeded — that difference is exactly what you wanted on the table. Lay the data alongside as shared reality, find out where the feeling comes from and, if needed, make a measuring agreement: 'we will look at it together again in six weeks'.

Try it yourself in Koach

Less admin, more coaching — starting at your next practice.

Get started with Koach